Chocolate Chip Cookie
Taste Test

This popular cookie is from the Old Fashioned line named after the village on Long Island. 


The Pepperidge Farm bakery was founded in 1937 by Margaret Rudkin who discovered fancy chocolate cookies on a trip in Europe which she then brought to the U.S. We found the cookie too soft and bland with an unpleasant aroma. 

Likes: None, despite the packaging that makes it look like an artisanal product and the high price that tends to make think they would be good 

Dislikes: Bland, soft to the point of having a sickly chewiness

Notes: 1 cookie (31 grams) is 140 calories and contains 12 grams of sugar, and 6 grams total fat (9% daily value). 

Price: $ 2.99 (purchased at Ralphs)