Chocolate Chip Cookie
Taste Test

This Southampton, NY, bakery makes cookies with natural ingredients and no additives or preservatives. 


This Southhampton-based bakery is known for their signature crisp chocolate chip cookie, so it's no surprise that it came out on top of our taste test. With its rich flavor and use of natural ingredients, the Tate's Bake Shop chocolate chip cookie tastes the way a cookie should. 

Likes: Rich flavor, good amount of chocolate chips, artisanal taste

Dislikes: You won't able to stop eating them; no wonder they're the most expensive of the ones we tasted

Notes: 2 cookies (28 grams) are 140 calories, and contains 12 grams of sugar, 7 grams total fat (11% daily value). 

Price: $3.79 (purchased at Whole Foods).

Price Comparison of the 5 tasted brands