The famous peanut butter beyond the chocolate cup. 


Their peanut butter cups make mouths water across the globe, so it makes sense to include Reese's peanut butter on this list. The brand actually started on a Hershey — yes, that Hershey — dairy farm where Harry Burnett Reese used to work.

Not surprisingly, we found the smooth, spreadable texture appealing. However, the flavor was so overwhelmingly salty we were tempted to chase it with chocolate to counteract the flavor. 

Likes: Easily spreadable, rich flavor

Dislikes: Too salty

Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt, peanut oil, monoglycerides, molasses, cornstarch, 190 calories (serving size: 2 tbsp)