Hotel Ratings in Long Island

Hotel Ratings in Long Island

GAYOT's star system rates each hotel property on its décor, service, amenities and ambience, from one star to five stars. To learn more about these ratings, click here.

Filter by
The room in one of the suites at the East Hampton Point Hotel.

East Hampton Point

Luxurious cottages and suites in a resort setting on the bay.
Huntting Inn

Huntting Inn

Expansive and historic inn and grounds in East Hampton Village.

Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate

This classic European-style castle enjoys a thoroughly all-American Long Island setting.

Topping Rose House

Authentic American history and sublime cuisine in the heart of the Hamptons.

The American Hotel

Luxury, history and gracious hospitality in the heart of an old whaling town.
Bassett House

Bassett House

A historic house with a gracious host provides the perfect hideaway in Montauk.

Clegg's Hotel

Low-key European ambience in the heart of the Fire Island nightlife scene.

East Hampton House Resort

This sprawling, all-balcony property is convenient to the Village of East Hampton.
The Hampton Maid

The Hampton Maid

A sprawling, woodsy retreat overlooking Shinnecock Bay.

Hyatt Place Garden City

A Garden City Hyatt Place ideal for those visiting nearby universities.