* Click here for rating key
Jimmy's Famous American Tavern Restaurant Review: After spending a few years in San Diego, restaurateur David Wilhelm returned to Orange County, where he built a devoted following spanning more than two decades. However, those familiar with Wilhelm’s past endeavors will see his softer side at this venue ensconced in the Dana Point harbor. The spacious restaurant juxtaposes floor-to-ceiling windows with warm woods and a vibrant living wall that fills the room with a lodge-like vibe. The resulting ambience works keenly with the nice list of libations, as well as the kitchen’s take on American comfort food. Start with a plate of the enormous beer-battered onion rings accompanied by house-made chipotle ketchup, or opt for the fire-grilled flatbread featuring pear, black fig jam, arugula, prosciutto and Maytag blue cheese. Mains feature beef, poultry and seafood dishes that are generous and balanced, highlighted by buttermilk fried chicken with garlic mashed potatoes and the heaping mound of farmhouse pappardelle served with chicken, peas, bacon and creamy Parmesan sauce. The compact dessert menu lists creative endings such as banana, vanilla and brown butter “Bananageddon.” The lunch crowd can come in from the docks to choose from a bevy of big burgers, sandwiches and salads.