Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

The Library at The Public

425 Lafayette St. (Astor Pl.) Send to Phone
212-539-8777 | Make Restaurant Reservations | Menu
Show-stopping American comfort food at The Public Theater.

Cuisine
Open
Dinner nightly
Features

* Click here for rating key

The Library at The Public, New York, NY

The Library at The Public Restaurant Review

: Step into the lobby of The Public Theater on Lafayette Street, turn left, go up the stairs and cross a hallway. Welcome to The Library, named as such because it once really was a library owned by the Astor family. Today, it’s a showcase for chef Andrew Carmellini (who created the menu) and for classic, well-made cocktails. Order a martini or an Old Fashioned and peruse the menu, divided up into Act I (starters), Act II (small-ish plates), Act III (larger plates) and dessert (of which there are only three uninspired offerings). Short rib goulash is a rich and hearty delight (especially on a cold night), and the burger, topped with caramelized onions, cheddar and bacon, is show-stoppingly good. Diners don’t need tickets to the show to eat at The Library; the real show, anyway, might be the Catskill Mountain trout --- skin on, bones out --- tender and flaky, and definitely worth an encore.
Check out hot NYC restaurants to try right now
Hot NYC Restaurants to Try Right Now

GAYOT's hottest NYC restaurants include an opulent chophouse, French fine-dining restaurant and a healthy paradise for vegetarians.



Find ideas for Mother's Day, including gifts and brunch restaurants
Mother's Day Guide

Find ideas for Mother's Day, including brunch restaurants, gifts and wines with GAYOT's Mother's Day Guide.



RESTAURANT AWARDS

GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards honor America's best chefs, as well as promising newcomers and a top restaurateur.