Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Old School Brooklyn

520 Court St. (Nelson St.) Send to Phone
718-407-0047 | Menu
Ignore the name and pay attention to what's on the plate and you'll leave this Carroll Gardens eatery happy.

Dinner nightly

* Click here for rating key

Old School Brooklyn Restaurant Review

: Don’t be fooled by the name. Sure, there are old framed family photos cramming the walls of this Carroll Gardens restaurant, giving the impression you’re in the home of someone’s nonna. But there’s nothing particularly “old school” about Old School Brooklyn. No spaghetti and meatballs. No pastrami sandwiches. No penne alla vodka. What you will encounter is simply straight up and satisfying Italian fare. Honey-drizzled baked ricotta, tender veal meatballs, and a creamy pork pâté make for great starters. Cavatelli combines with broccoli rabe and slightly spicy sausage, and oven-roasted cod, accompanied by tomatoes and olives, offers layers of flavor. Wine, offered by the glass, is affordable.
GAYOT has uncovered the best restaurants in New York for you to enjoy right now
Top 25 Restaurants in New York to Eat at Right Now

GAYOT's picks for the 25 hottest NYC restaurants include Italian hotspots, craft cocktail bars and eateries inspired by destinations around the globe.


GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards honor America's best chefs, as well as promising newcomers and a top restaurateur.