Sierra Mar
Post Ranch Inn
Pacific Coast Hwy. (Rte. 1, 30 miles S. of Carmel) 
Send to Phone
Big Sur, CA 93920
831-667-2800 | Make Restaurant Reservations
Cuisine
Open
Lunch & Dinner dailyFeatures
- View
- Romantic setting
- Full bar
- Reservations suggested
- Parking lot
- Casual dressy
Wine
Great Wine List* Click here for rating key
 A Lexus “shuttle” drops you at the front door of Sierra Mar, Post Ranch’s glass-walled sanctuary that impossibly hangs over the Pacific---a showcase for fine dining. This setting, with prices to boot, boosts expectations of chef Craig Von Foerster. To his credit, the food is picture perfect. But flavors fall short as does service. Dishes are dropped off without explanation; we feel as though we have to pry to find out the three different preparations of scallops. Though friendly, service operates on a pace all its own, perhaps that accounts for all dishes served lukewarm. A roasted heirloom tomato soup with grilled cheese sandwich sounds and looks mouthwatering. But the tiny triangles of brioche lack any flavor other than butter. And the soup’s salty flavor does indeed leave mouths watering. A striking dish of snowy grouper with roasted red pepper-almond relish and fork mashed olive oil potatoes almost wins us over---if only the grouper were not raw inside. Hitting the mark is fine pasta: melt-in-the-mouth artichoke agnolotti with porcini mushrooms. Desserts need retooling. A shortbread cookie under a smooth dome of coconut panna cotta is hard and does not yield to a fork---or a knife. Sorbet melts within seconds. And a “sundae” chocolate financier cake has the great looks, but forkfuls reveal dried-out cake and gluey caramel sauce. If only the food had the same jaw dropping effect as the majestic location. |
- Find deeply discounted gift certificates for restaurants in your area from Restaurant.com
- Plan Your Valentine's Day with Gayot's Guide to Romance
- Find the Best Heart-Healthy Restaurants Near You
What's Hot
Soothe
Whether you want a new hair regimen or new body care products, our favorite spa products will help you look and feel better. Check out Weleda's new Pomegranate Body Care Line, featuring organic pomegranate seed oil and more.
Sip
We've reviewed libations of all sorts—everything from Top Wines, Top 10 Vodkas, Top 10 Spirits and Top 10 Prestige Cuvées to bottled water and fine tea from around the world.
Give
Looking for a gift? You'll find great ideas for foodies and fashionistas, globetrotters and gourmands. Our categories include Top 10 Valentine's Day Gifts, Top Spa Gifts and more. Nothing like the present!
Serve
Try out a new international cuisine or plan your next dinner party with help from our cookbook reviews. We've explored everything from desserts and sweets to books by famous chefs from around the world.
RESTAURANT AWARDS
Just published! Our annual restaurant issue features the Best Cheap Eats and our Top 40 U.S. selections, including including Corton in New York and more!
