Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

The American Hotel

49 Main St. (Washington St.) Send to Phone
631-725-3535 | Menu
A historic Victorian dining room and extensive wine list make this restaurant a must for any celebration.

Breakfast, Lunch & Dinner daily
Bar open late

* Click here for rating key

The American Hotel, Sag Harbor, NY

The American Hotel Restaurant Review

: The American Hotel’s eclectic menu offers a satisfying blend of French bistro fare, classic American dining, and local Long Island ingredients. Seafood ranges from littleneck clams to Hog Neck oysters and Petrossian caviar. Long Island Peking duckling is a specialty. Carnivores have ample choices, with dry-aged Black Angus sirloin, filet mignon and a huge 36-ounce aged porterhouse prepared Florentine style. You can also feast on organic free-range chicken or calf’s liver. Sit under the skylight, dig into the encyclopedic wine list and watch the passing crowds of Sag Harbor.


Sign up to receive the 2019 edition of GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards. We honor America's best chefs, a top restaurateur and more.