2024 Best Seafood Restaurants in New York Area

Best Fresh Fish & Shellfish in New York

The best seafood is fresh, and prepared in such a way as to accent the natural flavors of the sea without overwhelming them. Some, like raw bar oysters and clams, need nothing more than a sharp knife and skilled hand to unleash the briny seasonings of the sea.

Presented in alphabetical order, here are the top seafood restaurants in New York.

> Also, check out GAYOT's:
- Seafood Restaurants in other cities
- Best Wines for Pairing with Seafood
- Guide to Seafood.
 

1/

Aldea

Portuguese, Seafood, Small Plates
Aldea
14/20
It takes a village: Aldea brings avant-garde Portuguese cuisine to Manhattan. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Greek, Mediterranean, Seafood
AVRA Madison
13/20
Pick your own fish at this Greek restaurant-club. See More
View Restaurant

3/

Catch

Seafood, Asian, American
Catch
14/20
Dining, drinking and clubbing come together at this Meatpacking District seafood spot. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
The Clam
13/20
Clam and seafood themed-restaurant from the folks who brought you Market Table. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Crave Fishbar
13/20
Creative seafood and a popular oyster happy hour on the Upper West Side. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Ed's Lobster Bar
13/20
A NoLIta seafood shack (via Cape Cod). See More
View Restaurant
Esca
16/20
A Southern Italian seafood eatery from chef David Pasternack. See More
View Restaurant
Estiatorio Milos
15/20
Seafood so fresh, the menu depends on the chef's “catch” at the fish market. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Flex Mussels
13/20
Taste the mussels from Brussels --- and Jamaica, and Thailand --- at this shellfish mecca. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Grand Central Oyster Bar & Restaurant
13/20
The best reason to miss your train is stopping for oysters at this Grand Central eatery. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant

Champagne Brut Delamotte;
WINE OF THE WEEK | GAYOT.com

A brut non-vintage Champagne from one of the five oldest Champagne houses. Read the article.