Navesink Fishery A&P Shopping Center AP Shopping Center A P Shopping Center Navesink Fishery

Navesink Fishery

A&P Shopping Center
1006 State Rte. 36 (Valley Dr.)
Middletown, NJ 07748
Cuisine: Seafood
Locals love this strip mall fish store for backroom dining on fresh seafood.
Openings: Lunch Tues.-Fri., Dinner Tues.-Sun.


Navesink Fishery, Middletown, NJ

Navesink Fishery Restaurant Review:

Park in the supermarket lot, venture in and then walk right past the seafood-filled refrigerated cases to the back room. This is where they’re cooking up fresh seafood; nothing fancy, with dishes ranging from oyster stew and pan-roasted flounder amandine to shrimp served dozens of ways. The menu offers a broad array of selections plus a few landlubber specialties. The broiled seafood combination platter is a treasure trove generous enough to be dinner and then lunch the next day. We recommend the chowder, either the white or red. Desserts are simple and sweet. Service is efficient.