Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Carlo & Johnny

9769 Montgomery Rd. (Bunker Hill Ln.) Send to Phone
With its 1933 gangster steakhouse theme, Carlo & Johnny recalls a time when "men were men and women were damn glad of it."

Dinner Mon.-Sat.
Open late Fri.-Sat.

* Click here for rating key

Carlo & Johnny, Montgomery, OH

Carlo & Johnny Restaurant Review

: In Cincinnati, there's such a thing as a "Jeff Ruby dining experience." Ruby has built a brand of steakhouses, and this one has all of his trademarks. Carlo & Johnny serves creative cuisine in plush, country club-like surroundings. Steeped in history and adorned with antiques --- including doorknobs from Al Capone’s winter home --- the building was once a private mansion, nightclub, speakeasy and illegal gambling joint. Legend goes that entertainer Kitty Kallen was singing “Mule Train” in December 1949 when the casino was raided. The restaurant is named in memory of the two cops who had a hand in the infamous raid. These days, the menu features Prime steaks, a vibrant bar scene and a raw bar with oysters, king crab and lobster. Sides to share range from truffled creamed sweet corn to baked macaroni and cheese. Meanwhile, desserts showcase a homemade ice cream sampler. Each of the three separate dining rooms has a distinct feel. With red leather banquettes, green velvet wall coverings and an eye-catching, lighted mermaid statue, the Emerald Room is pure old-world; the Ivory Room has hardwood floors and ceilings and unusual antique chandeliers; and the Grille Room has exposed brick walls, cathedral ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace, solid stone hearth and trophy animal heads on the walls. There are three wine cellars. Live music rounds out the experience.


GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards honor America's best chefs, as well as promising newcomers and a top restaurateur.