Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Townline BBQ

Townline Rd. & Montauk Hwy. Send to Phone
631-537-2271 | Order Now! | Menu
With rustic charm and a serious chef, this is barbecue served Hamptons-style.

Lunch & Dinner daily (summer only; rest of year open Wed.-Sun.)

* Click here for rating key

Townline BBQ, Sagaponack, NY

Townline BBQ Restaurant Review

: At this barbecue headquarters in Sagaponack where Johnny Cash rules and paper plates belie the seriousness of the chow, line up at the counter but leave your horse outside. Choose a seat in one of the roomy booths, at the long communal table, in the rustic wooden dining room, or the saloon. Chef Joe Realmuto (Nick & Toni’s, Rowdy Hall, La Fondita) traipsed through the barbecue trail and brought back a massive smoker along with his own interpretation of smoked meats. Pork ribs are meaty and moist with a hint of caramel; robust brisket can be had lean or moist (both winners); and smoked organic chicken is delicate and tender. Sides like sweet baked beans, buffalo fries and thick-cut fried onions should not be missed, and be sure to pick up some hush puppies with chipotle mayonnaise to share. Seasonal fried pies, a sugary version of the empanada, round out this Hamptons experience.


GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards honor America's best chefs, as well as promising newcomers and a top restaurateur.