Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Nick & Toni's

136 N. Main St. (Cedar St.) Send to Phone
631-324-3550 | Make Restaurant Reservations | Menu
Locally grown ingredients, Mediterranean fare and celebs galore---the only problem is getting in.
Your Opinion
Add your own review

Local Deals: 120 * 90

Dinner Wed.-Sun.

* Click here for rating key

  • 5.0 star rating
5.0 rating over 3 reviews
Dining room at Nick & Toni's, East Hampton, NY

Nick & Toni's Restaurant Review

: Consider yourself lucky if you're able to secure a table at Nick & Toni's. The huge wood-burning oven in the back of the dining room may be the star of the culinary show, but don’t be surprised if you find yourself dining next to real Hollywood stars. Patrons come in for the warm and attentive service as well as the creative Mediterranean fare prepared with care by chef Joe Realmuto. His focus is on local ingredients and organic produce grown in the restaurant’s own garden, and he delivers winners night after night. The local bay scallops are well paired with savory chanterelle mushrooms and a unique sorrel and walnut pesto. Whole roasted fish sprinkled with fragrant olive oil and fresh herbs is first-rate, as is the zucca pizza, a mix of butternut squash, robiola and bacon. Meat-lovers will enjoy the spice-rubbed hanger steak, served with local fingerling potatoes and a unique oyster butter. Maybe with the butterscotch panna cotta and a sip of limoncello you will muster the courage to ask for that autograph.

User Ratings & Reviews for Nick & Toni's


Check out the 2015 edition of GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Issue, which features the Top 40 Restaurants in the US and more.