Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

1031 E. 54th St. (College Ave.) Send to Phone
317-259-9412 | Menu
Experience a touch of Italy with classic dishes served in a charming stucco cottage.


Dinner Tues.-Sat.

* Click here for rating key

Operations may be disrupted due to COVID-19. Be sure to contact the restaurant to find out its current status and offerings.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant Restaurant Review

: The outdoor patio vibrant with fresh herbs and flowing vines belies the fact that downtown Indianapolis is only 10 minutes away and a busy rail trail is nearby. Inside, intimate dining rooms offer guests a chance to eat in semi privacy while enjoying the furnishings of this lovely former home. Sicilian-style asparagus patties can whet the appetite for the signature misto mare, with its abundance of shrimp, mussels, scallops and crab simmered in a spicy tomato sauce and set atop tender linguine. Angel hair pasta is ideal for soaking up the lemon and caper sauce served with chicken piccata. Consider, too, the tender ravioli. While the wine selection is limited, there is a decent array. For dessert, try the ricotta-filled cannoli.

Belgian chocolates

Coffee and chocolate make a delicious combination. ENJOY 10% OFF YOUR ENTIRE ORDER with GAYOT's exclusive promo code.

Stay in a romantic mood with this Rosé Champagne.

Read GAYOT's review.