Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.

Nick & Toni's Cafe

100 W. 67th St. (Broadway) Send to Phone
212-496-4000 | Make Restaurant Reservations | Order Now! | Menu
Upper West Side offshoot of an East Hampton restaurant for Italian cuisine and a global wine list.

Lunch Mon.-Fri., Dinner nightly, Brunch Sat.-Sun.

* Click here for rating key

Nick & Toni's Cafe Restaurant Review

: If you’re unfamiliar with this Upper West Side restaurant’s East Hampton sibling of the same name, scan the menu and you’ll see it’s Italian all the way, from the ultra-creamy burrata caprese, complete with arugula pesto, to the deeply rich sausage ragù with pappardelle, and the crisp Caesar salad. Hearty mains, or secondi, range from a juicy, golden brown grilled pork chop to a substantial rib-eye. Desserts include silky ricotta cheesecake and a crumbly Meyer lemon tart. The global wine list offers better value by the bottle than by the glass.
Check out hot NYC restaurants to try right now
Hot NYC Restaurants to Try Right Now

GAYOT's hottest NYC restaurants include an opulent chophouse, French fine-dining restaurant and a healthy paradise for vegetarians.

Find ideas for Mother's Day, including gifts and brunch restaurants
Mother's Day Guide

Find ideas for Mother's Day, including brunch restaurants, gifts and wines with GAYOT's Mother's Day Guide.


GAYOT's Annual Restaurant Awards honor America's best chefs, as well as promising newcomers and a top restaurateur.