Since 1969, restaurant, hotel, travel & other witty reviews by a handpicked, worldwide team of discerning professionals—and your views, too.


104 W. 57th St. (Sixth & Seventh Aves.) Send to Phone
A wildly eclectic and popular
Your Opinion
Add your own review

Local Deals: 120 * 90

Lunch Mon.-Sat., Dinner nightly, Brunch Sun.

* Click here for rating key

  • 5.0 star rating
5.0 rating over 1 reviews

THIS RESTAURANT IS CLOSED Shelly's New York Restaurant Review

: The ever-nostalgic Shelly Fireman has done it again with a New York-themed eatery. Only Fireman has the guts to open a string of New York-themed restaurants in New York. His others are Fireman's of Brooklyn and Brooklyn Diner. (He also owns Trattoria dell Arte and Redeye Grill.) At his latest, the menu runs the gamut of New York food: from hamburgers to foie gras, lobster to fish 'n' chips, aged beef to Chinese. The four-level emporium---in the former home of Motown Café, a theme palace that didn't make it---also spans a broad range. A martini lounge, dance floor and terrace garden, as well as almost 300 seats for diners, make up the mix. We suppose people are more attracted to the spectacle then the food, as is the case in several of Fireman's eateries.

User Ratings & Reviews for THIS RESTAURANT IS CLOSED Shelly's New York
GAYOT has uncovered the best restaurants in New York for you to enjoy right now
Top 25 Restaurants in New York to Eat at Right Now

GAYOT's picks include Italian hotspots, craft cocktail bars and eateries inspired by destinations around the globe.

Read more


Discover the best female chefs, top pizzerias and stellar seafood restaurants with GAYOT's Top 10 lists of the best restaurants in America.