Top 10 Steakhouses in New York

By Gayot Editors

NYC’s Best Steaks

Face it: You may be a master of the barbecue grill, but it’s next to impossible for you to buy top restaurant-quality beef or broil it at temperatures as high as these NYC steakhouses can. From old-fashioned meat joints to modern chophouses, those that made the cut all have one thing in common: great steak. Tuck into your favorite cuts, or try new ones, at one of GAYOT’s Top 10 Steakhouses in New York.

> The selections are presented in alphabetical order.

1. American Cut Steakhouse Tribeca


TriBeCa, New York, NY

Reservation OpenTable

Marc Forgione explores all things steak at this TriBeCa restaurant.

RESERVE NOW!

2. Benjamin Prime


Midtown East, New York, NY

Reservation OpenTable

Benjamin Prime updates the steakhouse concept with contemporary versions of beloved dishes.

RESERVE NOW!

3. CUT


Financial District, New York, NY

Reservation OpenTable

Wolfgang Puck’s CUT steakhouse prides itself on serving Japanese and American cuts, grilled over hardwood and finished in a 1200° broiler.

RESERVE NOW!

4. Keens Steakhouse


Midtown West, New York, NY

Eclectic memorabilia and satisfying steakhouse fare prove a pleasing combination at this Midtown eatery.

5. M. Wells Steakhouse


Long Island City, NY

M. Wells Steakhouse in Long Island City features a menu loaded with meaty goodness.

6. Peter Luger


Brooklyn, NY

New York’s quintessential steakhouse never disappoints.

7. Porter House New York


Midtown West, New York, NY

Reservation OpenTable

This meaty retreat in Time Warner Center offers views of Central Park from its fourth floor perch.

RESERVE NOW!

8. Quality Meats

Reservation OpenTable


Midtown West, New York, NY

Quality Meats puts a wry spin on the traditional beef emporiums that pepper New York City.

RESERVE NOW!

9. St. Anselm


Brooklyn, NY

St. Anselm is like a steakhouse for hipsters; a veritable grilled meat mecca for the skinny jeans set.

10. Uncle Jack’s Steakhouse

Reservation OpenTable


Midtown West, New York, NY

This old-style steakhouse gives new meaning to the name Meatpacking District.

RESERVE NOW!