2019 Best Restaurants with the Best Food in Long Island (NY) Area

Top Rated Restaurants
in Long Island (NY)

When it comes to reviewing and recommending restaurants, we believe that what is on the plate is by far the most important factor. We rate the food on a 20-point scale. Our take on the décor, service, ambience, wine list and other factors are explored within our full reviews, which are simply a click away.

Presented in alphabetical order, these Top 10 Restaurants earned the highest food ratings in Long Island (NY).
 
14/20
Where the Bronx and Florence unite on Long Island. See More
View Restaurant
14/20
Fresh, seafood-heavy “farm-to-table” pan-Asian cuisine. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant

3/

Lola

Middle Eastern, Mediterranean
14/20
Lola’s makeover brings a Mediterranean and Middle Eastern flair to Great Neck. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
14/20
Waterside views and a classic surf ‘n’ turf menu with a sushi bar. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
14/20
Contemporary American cuisine and French brasserie classics in a sophisticated yet fun atmosphere. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Nick & Toni's
14/20
Locally grown ingredients, Mediterranean fare and celebs galore --- the only problem is getting in. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
The North Fork Table & Inn
15/20
On-trend inn restaurant serving local Long Island fare. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Pierre's
14/20
It's St. Tropez meets South Beach at this elegant eatery and pâtisserie run by a fifth generation Alsatian baker. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Prime Restaurant
14/20
Prime views and American cuisine on Huntington Harbor. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
The 1770 House
15/20
Hamptons inn offering contemporary American cuisine in two atmospheres. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant