2020 Best Restaurants with the Best Food in Indianapolis Area

Top Rated Restaurants
in Indianapolis

When it comes to reviewing and recommending restaurants, we believe that what is on the plate is by far the most important factor. We rate the food on a 20-point scale. Our take on the décor, service, ambience, wine list and other factors are explored within our full reviews, which are simply a click away.

Presented in alphabetical order, these Top 10 Restaurants earned the highest food ratings in Indianapolis.
 
14/20
Urban gastropub sets the standard for out-of-the-ordinary flavor combinations that work. See More
View Restaurant
The Capital Grille
14/20
First-rate steaks, chic surroundings and sophisticated warmth appeal to more than just suits. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
FARMrestaurant at FARMbloomington
13/20
A contemporary approach and folksy environs keep this college town restaurant a destination. See More
View Restaurant
Mesh on Mass Avenue
14/20
Neighborhood restaurant with an “in” crowd, solid sandwiches and innovative small plates and entrées. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
Oakleys Bistro
16/20
Suburban Oakley’s masters the art of marrying flavors. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
The Oceanaire Seafood Room
14/20
A favorite among locals and visitors in search of topnotch seafood and a tony environment. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
14/20
Neighborhood café with a French accent. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
St. Elmo Steak House
14/20
Shrimp cocktail with its hotter-than-hot sauce is as famous as the New York strip at this Indianapolis landmark. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant
14/20
Sakura continues to distinguish itself with its sushi and Japanese fare. See More
View Restaurant
Sullivan's Steakhouse
14/20
Celebrate with a filet and a chilled martini, or go for the jazz and scotch. See More

Book a Table

View Restaurant